WATER
4Silent Sea Nettle
ATK:
800
DEF:
1300
View:
3873
If you control a WATER monster: You can Special Summon this card from your hand. You cannot Special Summon monsters, except WATER monsters, the turn you activate this effect. You can banish this card from your GY, then target up to 3 WATER monsters in your GY; shuffle them into the Deck. You can only use each effect of "Silent Sea Nettle" once per turn.
Silent Sea Nettle — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 61 ± 7 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 61 · Deck: 62 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Extender · Secondary: Material body, Recovery/Recursion
Why it scores here
Silent Sea Nettle is a cheap, generic WATER extender: a free Level-4 body from hand plus a Graveyard recycle, which is why it shows up in 400/400 sampled decks across 43 distinct archetypes and is filed under 'Staple' in four separate guides. Its power sits in accessibility and material utility - the body feeds Bahamut Shark, Number 4: Stealth Kragen and generic Link/Xyz lines - not in disruption, since neither effect interacts with the opponent. The 800 ATK / 1300 DEF stat line earns nothing here; the score rewards reliable extension and low deck cost, and is held back by the WATER-only Special Summon lock that keeps it from being truly generic. With zero recorded combos, combo conversion was scored conservatively from card text alone.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 58 | The hand Special Summon is live only while controlling a WATER monster, but the card appears in 400/400 sampled decks across 43 archetypes and at 100% inclusion in Fishborg (observed). |
| Combo & Conversion | 55 | Card text yields one free Level-4 WATER body per turn; with 0 recorded combos it can only extend an existing line rather than start one (inferred). |
| Resource Economy | 52 | The body itself is card-neutral and the GY effect banishes itself to shuffle up to 3 WATER monsters back into the Deck - a recycle, not real advantage (verified). |
| Effect & Interaction | 5 | Neither effect negates, removes, or disrupts the opponent in any way (verified). |
| Material Utility | 75 | A Level-4 WATER Aqua that converts into Bahamut Shark / Number 4: Stealth Kragen (69.5% co-deck rate) and generic Link material even if its effect is negated (observed). |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 62 | Usable from two zones (hand and Graveyard) and still a clean Level-4 body when blanked, though each effect resolves only once per turn (verified). |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 72 | 1.51 average copies, 100% main-decked in the sample, and the WATER-only Special Summon lock is effectively free inside a mono-WATER shell (observed). |
Calculation
Weight profile: 0.7 Extender + 0.3 Material body. Intrinsic ≈ 61, Deck ≈ 62, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: Self-locking WATER-only Special Summon restriction (-2); Exceptional splashability inside the WATER pool (2). Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Free Level-4 WATER body from hand with no archetype requirement
- Second effect recycles up to 3 WATER monsters from the Graveyard into the Deck
- Clean generic material for Bahamut Shark, Number 4: Stealth Kragen and Link plays
- Extremely cheap to run: 1.51 average copies, essentially all main deck
Weaknesses
- Requires an existing WATER monster on board before it can summon itself
- WATER-only Special Summon lock for the turn after the hand effect resolves
- Provides zero disruption, negation or removal
- Low 800/1300 body means it does not threaten on its own
- Both effects are once per turn each
Counters / choke points
- Graveyard hate that removes it before the banish-from-GY recycle resolves
- Effects or locks that prevent WATER Special Summons, which the card's own lock also enforces
- Spot removal aimed at the WATER monster you needed to control to summon it
- Board punishers that punish the wide Xyz/Link boards it helps build
Best use
Free WATER Level-4 extender and Xyz/Link material provider, with a Graveyard recycle mode. Decks: Shark, Marincess, Icejade, Mermail, Atlantean, Fishborg, Ice Barrier, Umi.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card text: 'If you control a WATER monster: You can Special Summon this card from your hand' with a WATER-only Special Summon lock for the turn.; Card text: banish this card from the GY to target up to 3 WATER monsters in your GY and shuffle them into the Deck.; Card text: each effect of 'Silent Sea Nettle' can only be used once per turn.; Card identity: Level 4 WATER Aqua Effect Monster, 800 ATK / 1300 DEF, no archetype, legal in TCG, OCG and Master Duel.
- Observed: Appears in 400/400 sampled decks, 100% in the main deck, averaging 1.51 copies (223 decks at 1, 151 at 2, 26 at 3).; 43 distinct archetypes use it; Shark leads (29.2% + 16.8%), then Marincess (11% + 4.5%), Icejade (7.5%), Mermail and Atlantean (4.2% each).; Top partners include Called by the Grave (82.8%), Infinite Impermanence (78%), Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring (76.5%), Bahamut Shark and Number 4: Stealth Kragen (both 69.5%).; Four guides list it in 'Staple' sections (Shark, Ice Barrier, Marincess) and under 'WATER Extender' in the Shark Kragen guide.; usage statistics show Fishborg at 100% inclusion with 3 typical copies.; combo data contains 0 combos, so no recorded starter/material/payoff split exists.
- Inferred: The free Level-4 WATER body extends into Xyz plays (Bahamut Shark, Number 4: Stealth Kragen) and generic Link material.; The Graveyard shuffle effect supports grind by returning WATER monsters to the Deck but is not card advantage by itself.; The WATER-only Special Summon lock is a negligible cost in a pure WATER deck but blocks non-WATER extension routes.; Its high co-deck rates with Shark Xyz pieces indicate it functions as material rather than as a payoff.
- Data gaps: no combos supplied — combo conversion is text-only inference no banlist token — assumed 3 copies (unlimited) usage statistics cover only a single archetype (Fishborg), so cross-archetype inclusion rates are unavailable no ruling detail on timing interactions between the hand effect and the WATER lock






